To watch or not to watch, that is the question.

There are shows I actively want to watch. Then there are shows that stand at the edge of my viewing queue like a charismatic outlaw, tipping a hat and saying, “You know you want to.”

Yellowstone falls squarely into that second category.

The reason is simple: Beth Dutton.

Even as someone who has never watched the show properly, I’ve seen enough clips to understand the appeal. Beth is bitter, fierce, relentless, and apparently incapable of leaving a thought unspoken. She storms through scenes like a wildfire that has learned how to wear expensive coats.

I completely understand why people love her.

But I also understand why people can’t stand her.

In fact, one of the funniest things about reading fan discussions is discovering that Beth may be one of the most divisive television characters of the last decade. Reddit threads are full of people arguing over whether she’s the best thing about Yellowstone or the reason they almost quit watching. Some viewers describe her as a scene-stealer. Others call her exhausting, cartoonishly aggressive, or so consumed by anger that she overwhelms every scene she’s in. A recurring complaint is that she rarely seems to soften, making her feel less like a person and more like a force of nature.

Oddly enough, those criticisms are part of what attracts me.

I don’t mind difficult characters. I like characters who carry old wounds around like unpaid debts. Beth seems to be built entirely from old wounds. The problem is everything around her. Every clip I stumble across looks like it emerged from a blender filled with blood, rage, and profanity. Someone always seems to be bruised. Someone always seems to be bleeding. Beth herself often appears to be either furious, injured, or both at the same time.

And then there’s the language.

I genuinely don’t think I’ve managed to watch a two-minute clip without hearing enough F-bombs to populate a small dictionary. Every conversation sounds like it’s one insult away from becoming a bar fight. The moment that really made me pause was hearing younger characters use language that felt surprisingly extreme. When Carter said it, I raised an eyebrow. When Tate Dutton said something similar, my reaction was basically: that’s a bit much.

Maybe that makes me sound old-fashioned.

Maybe I am old-fashioned.

But there comes a point where constant swearing stops sounding natural and starts sounding like punctuation with anger issues. I couldn’t watch the show knowing my ears won’t bleed.

To be fair, the show’s reputation doesn’t exactly suggest restraint. Even many fans describe Yellowstone as a highly dramatic world where violence, revenge, and escalating feuds are the fuel that keeps the engine running. The franchise itself is known for its brutal confrontations and high body count.

So here I am. Tempted by Beth. Repelled by everything else.

I suspect that if someone extracted Beth Dutton from Yellowstone and dropped her into a different show with half the blood and a quarter of the profanity, I’d probably watch the entire thing.

Until then, Yellowstone remains in a special category: The series that almost convinced me.

•     Subscribe to my blog.
•     Find  my books on Amazon.
•     Show some love!

Shabana Mukhtar